home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1692>
- <title>
- Dec. 05, 1994: Middle East:The Seeds of Civil War
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Dec. 05, 1994 50 for the Future
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- MIDDLE EAST, Page 82
- The Seeds of Civil War
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> With Arafat loyalists and Hamas militants exchanging threats,
- turmoil intensifies in the Gaza Strip
- </p>
- <p>By Lisa Beyer--With reporting by Jamil Hamad/Gaza City
- </p>
- <p> The graffiti that covered the white concrete walls of Gaza
- City during the Israeli occupation are back. Freshly scrawled
- slogans denounce and threaten in language as bloodcurdling as
- that used during the intifadeh--only this time Palestinians
- are cursing one another, not Israel. RATS, RETURN TO YOUR HOLES,
- OR ELSE, the Fatah faction warns the more militant Hamas group,
- which replies, A TRAITOR IS HE WHO FIRED AT OUR PEOPLE. On another
- wall is the vow FATAH ZEALOTS WILL CHOP OFF THE HEADS OF CONSPIRATORS.
- Hamas' counterwarning: THE RETRIBUTION WILL COME WITHOUT YOU
- EVEN HEARING IT.
- </p>
- <p> So much for the notion of Palestinian unity. Bloody Friday took
- care of that the day two weeks ago when the security forces
- of Yasser Arafat's Palestinian Authority opened fire on Hamas
- supporters and the Islamic Jihad rioting outside the Palestine
- Mosque in Gaza City and provoked street battles that killed
- 13 people and left 200 wounded. A few days later, in a Palestinian
- refugee camp in southern Lebanon, Arafat loyalists were fighting
- other opponents of the peace deal with Israel, this time dissidents
- within Fatah. While infighting in Lebanon is an old phenomenon,
- in the Gaza Strip, it was something new. "All the factions had
- sworn that they would never resort to violence," said Ziad Abu-Amr,
- an expert on Islamic fundamentalism at Bir Zeit University in
- the West Bank. "Now taboos have been broken. The glass has been
- shattered. So we are waiting for another round. Are the conditions
- of the first round still present? Yes, and more."
- </p>
- <p> Round 2 threatened to come quickly when Hamas, which is struggling
- with Arafat for the soul of the Palestinians, held a mass rally
- last Saturday afternoon that attracted 20,000 people. The demonstration,
- however, passed peaceably. By agreement, Arafat's security forces
- stayed away, while Hamas refrained from public displays of weaponry
- and sent supporters directly home. Still, negotiations to achieve
- anything beyond a temporary cease-fire between Arafat and his
- opposition were foundering. "Our task is worse than very difficult,"
- said Ahmed Tibi, an Israeli Arab working to bring about a reconciliation
- between the two factions. At one point the truce talks broke
- down over the Palestinian Authority's refusal to accept responsibility
- for the mayhem outside the mosque. Arafat and his aides blamed
- the bloodshed on third parties: Israel, Palestinians collaborating
- with Israel, and Iran, a patron of Hamas.
- </p>
- <p> Arafat's spirits were temporarily buoyed when 10,000 Gazans
- rallied for him last week. Among them were several hundred Fatah
- Hawks, a military branch of Arafat's Fatah faction of the Palestine
- Liberation Organization. The Hawks, who had been ignored of
- late by Arafat, swore, in chanted slogans, to defend him and
- the Authority. The militiamen then drove around the Gaza Strip,
- brandishing their guns and shouting slogans such as, "We shall
- shave the beards ((of the Islamists)) with our shoes."
- </p>
- <p> The Hawks' demonstration inflamed Arafat's opponents in Gaza.
- "This show of muscle was a big mistake," said Mansour Shawa,
- president of the charitable Benevolent Society for the Gaza
- Strip. "It just provoked a lot of people." By aligning himself
- with a factional militia, critics said, the chairman had undercut
- his claim to be a national leader. "He is going back to acting
- like the head of a gang," said Ghazi Abu Jayyab, an activist
- in the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. Bloody
- Friday also tainted the image of the Authority's 9,000-member
- Gaza Strip security force. "The uncommitted, nonpolitical man
- in the street is now hostile to the police," said Akram Ibrahim,
- a Gaza cabdriver and former Fatah activist.
- </p>
- <p> Most observers do not expect the Hamas leadership to provoke
- civil war deliberately, at least not now. Instead of aiming
- its fire at Arafat's forces, Hamas is expected to zero in on
- Israeli targets. During noon prayers at the Palestine Mosque
- last Friday, Sheik Said Siam vowed, "Our weapons will not accept
- any address except the chests of the Zionist enemy." Since Bloody
- Friday, there have been seven attacks or attempted attacks on
- Israeli soldiers and settlers in the Gaza Strip.
- </p>
- <p> Whether the Hamas leadership speaks for the most radical elements
- in the organization, however, remains a question. "The militant,
- hard-line trend is dominant now, and the prevailing notion that
- Mr. Arafat is in deep trouble pushes them forward," said Abu-Amr.
- Referring to the Oct. 19 suicide bombing of a Tel Aviv bus that
- killed 22 people, a Hamas leader added, "Have no doubt, some
- people are ready to imitate what happened in Tel Aviv in the
- center of Arafat's Authority." Civil war could also be provoked
- by Arafat's security forces, which include men who believe that
- now is the time to finish off Hamas.
- </p>
- <p> Cooler heads in Hamas' ranks have begun to talk about disavowing
- internecine violence in the Gaza Strip in return for being allowed
- a role in the Authority. Would Arafat go along? Before Bloody
- Friday, the chairman had appointed a Hamas member to serve on
- the Muslim religious courts in the West Bank, but in the wake
- of the fracas, he may no longer be interested in sharing power
- at any level.
- </p>
- <p> An improvement in the sad economic shape of the Gaza Strip would
- help limit the appeal of Hamas--which is why Palestinian officials,
- backed by the U.S. and Israel, will lobby international donors
- this week in Brussels to give the Palestinian Authority significant
- funding. Foreign aid is especially important now, since, as
- Khaled Abdul-Shafi, a Gaza economist, notes, "what happened
- last Friday reduces the chances of private investment to zero."
- </p>
- <p> While some Israeli commentators see the conflict in the Gaza
- Strip as the beginning of the end for Hamas and other fundamentalist
- radicals, Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin's government is alarmed
- by the developments. "Last Friday opened Israeli minds to how
- fragile the whole peace process is," said Uri Dromi, director
- of the Government Press Office. "And Rabin is also invested
- in this. What can he tell the Israeli people? That he was wrong
- to make peace with Arafat?"
- </p>
- <p> One school of thought in the government argues that Palestinian
- self-rule should be limited to the Gaza Strip and Jericho and
- not expanded, as promised, to the rest of the West Bank--at
- least until Arafat proves he can effectively govern Gaza. The
- alternate view holds that Israel must help Arafat by granting
- him a political victory, namely extending autonomy to the West
- Bank as soon as possible. Dromi believes the second school will
- win out.
- </p>
- <p> In the meantime, the situation in Gaza remains perilous. Warns
- Mansour Shawa: "If the path is not corrected, we are heading
- for calamity. Any future confrontation--any--will lead to
- widespread violence." Whatever the remedy, it had better come
- quickly, lest the slogans on Gaza's walls turn out to be prophetic.
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-